5 Carat Diamond Ring Price Guide (2026) | The Luxury Tier
5 carat diamond ring prices from our tracker: lab-grown G/VS1 rounds from $4,790, natural from $174,304 on 1 November 2026. Setting cost too.
Founder of TheCaratCut. Director and software engineer with experience leading software for UFC, Al Jazeera, AMCN, The Economist, and The NHS. Director at Wayfinity, founder of Seat and Stone, and runs The Developer Safe Place mentorship community. Not a GIA-certified gemologist, and nothing here has been bought or tested — articles draw on retailers' published policies, prices and certificates and on customer-review sites. Most were first drafted with AI tools and are being re-checked against their sources, with AI help; every correction is approved by David before it goes live.
Last reviewed and updated 17 November 2026 by The Carat Cut editorial team. The diamond prices on this page are read from retailer listings each month by our Diamond Price Tracker. We have not bought, handled or tested any of these stones, and nobody here is a gemologist.
Key takeaways
- •Lab-grown 5 carat rounds in G colour, VS1 clarity and Ideal or Super Ideal cut started at $4,790 (Brilliant Earth) in our 1 November 2026 sample, with a median of $4,850 across 27 listings.
- •The natural sample found 2 stones of this grade, both at Blue Nile: the cheapest cost $174,304, and the median of the two, which is simply the midpoint between them, was $177,496. Brilliant Earth listed none.
- •The natural sample at this weight is small, and the count is given beside every figure: read the natural price as what was on sale that day, not as a market price.
- •A 5 carat round is about 11 mm across (10.97 mm on StoneAlgo's size chart) and weighs one gram.
- •These are prices for the loose stone. A setting is extra; a dated example is below.
A 5 carat diamond costs very different amounts depending on whether it was mined or grown. The grading laboratory GIA says that of two diamonds equal in colour, clarity and cut, the heavier one "would be more rare" and likely to cost more (GIA, checked 17 November 2026). Lab-grown prices have gone the other way: the diamond analyst Paul Zimnisky has said they fell by about 85% between January 2015 and January 2025, as Money reported on 17 April 2026. Our own sample shows both halves of that. On 1 November 2026 one retailer listed 27 lab-grown 5 carat rounds of a single grade, and the two retailers we read listed 2 natural ones between them. This guide gives the prices our tracker recorded for that grade, how they compare with lighter stones, what a setting adds, and how to check a retailer's price against them.
How much does a 5 carat diamond cost?
We sample one grade at this weight: a round stone of 5.00 to 5.05 carats, G colour, VS1 clarity, in Ideal, Super Ideal or Excellent cut. On 1 November 2026 the cheapest lab-grown stone of that grade cost $4,790 at Brilliant Earth, and the median of the 27 stones listed was $4,850. The natural sample found 2 stones of this grade, both at Blue Nile: the cheapest cost $174,304, and the median of the two, which is simply the midpoint between them, was $177,496. Brilliant Earth listed none. The table gives each retailer's lowest price, its median and the number of stones it listed. These are prices for the loose stone; the setting is covered further down.
| 5.00 ct round, G / VS1 | Retailer | Lowest, 1 November 2026 | Median | Stones listed | Lowest, 14 October 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lab-grown | Brilliant Earth | $4,790 | $4,850 | 27 | $4,800 |
| Natural | Blue Nile | $174,304 | $177,496 | 2 | no listing |
| Natural | Brilliant Earth | no listing | — | 0 | no listing |
Advertised US list prices for loose stones of 5.00 to 5.05 carats in Ideal, Super Ideal or Excellent cut, read by our Diamond Price Tracker from Brilliant Earth’s product feed and Blue Nile’s listings. “No listing” means the retailer showed no stone of this weight and grade on that date. Setting not included. We have not sampled any other colour or clarity grade at this weight.
The counts matter more here than on our guides to lighter stones. The lowest price is one stone, and it moves or disappears when that stone sells. On 14 October 2026 the cheapest lab-grown stone in the same basket was $4,800, among 25 listed. On 14 October 2026 neither retailer listed a natural stone of this grade at all, so there is no earlier natural price to compare. For comparison, the same two retailers listed 200 natural 1 carat rounds of this grade on 1 November 2026 and 5 at 4 carats. A natural 5 carat price drawn from so few stones tells you what those stones were offered at; it cannot tell you what the next one will cost.
We have not sampled 5 carat stones in any other colour or clarity, so this guide no longer gives prices for them. GIA's point that two diamonds of the same carat weight "aren't necessarily equal" applies: a higher colour or clarity grade costs more and a lower one costs less, and the way to find out how much is to change one filter at a time in a retailer's search and watch the price.
How the price climbs with carat weight
Our tracker samples the same grade at seven weights, and 5 carats is the heaviest. On 1 November 2026 the cheapest natural G/VS1 round cost $81,654 at 4 carats and $174,304 at 5 carats. For lab-grown stones the same two steps were $3,650 and $4,790.
Per carat, the cheapest natural 5 carat stone worked out at $34,861, against $2,880 per carat for the cheapest natural 1 carat stone: 12.1× as much for each carat. For lab-grown stones the same comparison gives 1.9×.
| Carat weight | Lowest lab-grown | Lowest natural | Natural, per carat | Lab-grown as a share of natural | Stones listed (lab-grown / natural) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 ct | $510 | $2,880 | $2,880 | 18% | 69 / 200 |
| 1.5 ct | $920 | $7,390 | $4,927 | 12% | 93 / 61 |
| 2 ct | $1,320 | $14,390 | $7,195 | 9.2% | 146 / 50 |
| 2.5 ct | $2,180 | $22,850 | $9,140 | 9.5% | 75 / 32 |
| 3 ct | $2,570 | $42,782 | $14,261 | 6.0% | 73 / 16 |
| 4 ct | $3,650 | $81,654 | $20,414 | 4.5% | 35 / 5 |
| 5 ct | $4,790 | $174,304 | $34,861 | 2.7% | 27 / 2 |
Lowest advertised price for a round G / VS1 stone at each weight on 1 November 2026, from the same two retailers. Each figure is a single stone, so it moves when that stone sells, and the fewer stones listed, the less a row says about the market.
One thing in the lab-grown figures needs saying: the median for 5 carat stones ($4,850 across 27 listings) was below the median for 4 carat stones ($7,180 across 35 listings) in the same sample. Each median describes a few dozen stones listed by one retailer on one day, and those stones differ in more than weight, so do not read the two as a rule that 5 carat lab-grown stones cost less than 4 carat ones.
Our 4 carat diamond price guide covers the next weight down from the same tracker.
Live sampled prices
This is the same sample as it appears on the tracker, with a link to each retailer and a note on how the stones were matched. A retailer that listed no stone at this exact weight and grade shows no price rather than a substitute. At 5 carats an empty natural row is not unusual: of the 2 dated samples our tracker holds for this basket, 1 had no natural stone at either retailer. Where two retailers have a price, the three boxes above the table give the lowest, average and highest of those two retailers' lowest prices; they are not the market's range. Where only one retailer has a price, all three boxes show that one stone.
Only two retailers are sampled. When we sampled 1 carat stones by hand across more sellers in May 2026, every branded retailer's lowest price was above the Rare Carat marketplace median (see the tracker history), so treat these as reference prices rather than a market floor.
Live sampled prices: 5 carat round, G VS1
Lowest in-spec listing per retailer, lab-grown and natural. Re-sampled monthly.
| Retailer | Lowest price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Brilliant Earth | $4,790 | 27 in-spec stones listed, median $4,850. Ideal and Super Ideal cuts, 5.00–5.05 ct, read from Brilliant Earth's product feed. |
| Retailer | Lowest price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Blue Nile | $174,304 | 2 in-spec stones listed, median $177,496. Excellent and Ideal cuts, 5.00–5.05 ct, read from Blue Nile's listing (all 2 matches shown). |
| Brilliant Earth | — | No natural round listed at 5.00–5.05 ct in G/VS1, Ideal or Super Ideal cut, on the sample date. |
What a 5 carat diamond ring costs with the setting
A ring is the stone plus a setting, and retailers that sell loose stones price the two separately. We do not track setting prices. As one dated reading: on 16 November 2026 the first six settings shown on Blue Nile's engagement ring page (bluenile.com/engagement-rings) had list prices from $1,000 (a 14k gold petite solitaire) to $2,320 (an 18k gold solitaire), before a 20% sale discount that was running that day. Blue Nile listed 1,431 settings, so those six are a reading of the first page, not its cheapest or dearest. Check that a setting takes a 5 carat centre stone before you choose it.
On those figures, the cheapest natural 5 carat G/VS1 round Blue Nile listed in our sample ($174,304) in one of those settings comes to between $175,304 and $176,624 at list price. Even the dearer setting is about 1.3% of the price of that stone. With the cheapest lab-grown stone in our sample ($4,790), the same settings give $5,790 to $7,110, so the setting is a much larger share of a lab-grown ring's total. Compare settings as carefully as stones.
Lab-grown vs natural at 5 carats
In our 1 November 2026 sample the cheapest lab-grown 5 carat G/VS1 round ($4,790 at Brilliant Earth) cost about 2.7% of the cheapest natural one ($174,304 at Blue Nile), a saving of 97%. In the same sample no other weight we track showed a lower lab-grown share, so on these figures the gap is widest at 5 carats. The table above gives the share at every weight we sample. At 5 carats it rests on 2 stones on the natural side, so a single sale can change it.
- Lab-grown buys size. The cheapest lab-grown 5 carat stone in our sample cost $4,790; for comparison, the cheapest natural 1 carat stone of the same grade cost $2,880.
- Natural costs many times more for a stone graded the same. Do not count on getting the difference back: our guide to lab diamond resale value quotes trade sources saying lab-grown stones resell for little or nothing, and a jewellers' trade body saying only that a high-quality natural diamond "may" hold its value.
One thing to know when comparing grades across the two. GIA announced on 2 June 2025 that it "will no longer use the color and clarity nomenclature that GIA developed for natural diamonds" for laboratory-grown stones (GIA, checked 17 November 2026), and since 1 October 2025 it has classed them as "Premium" or "Standard" instead (GIA, 26 August 2025, checked 17 November 2026). The "G / VS1" on a lab-grown stone in our sample is the grade shown in the retailer's listing.
For broader context see our lab-grown vs natural diamond price chart. If you are considering an even larger stone, see our 6 carat diamond rings guide; our tracker does not sample that weight.
The "big stone" rules
None of this comes from handling stones, and none of it is a rule we have tested. It is what the grading laboratory and a retailer's buying guides say about large diamonds, applied to this size.
Cut. GIA grades the cut of a round brilliant on a scale from Excellent to Poor, and gives cut grades only to round brilliants (GIA, checked 17 November 2026). Excellent is the top of that scale; the "Ideal" and "Super Ideal" in our sample are the cut labels Brilliant Earth's listings use. An "AGS Ideal" grade is no longer a separate laboratory's verdict: the American Gem Society closed its laboratory at the end of 2022, and the AGS Ideal report became a paid digital supplement to a GIA report, as Rapaport reported on 20 October 2022. Our sample only counts Ideal, Super Ideal and Excellent stones, so the prices above already assume a top cut grade. A 5 carat oval, emerald or pear cut comes with no GIA cut grade and has to be judged from its measurements and images.
Colour. Blue Nile's colour guide classes D to F as colourless and G to J as near-colourless, says platinum or white gold "will make a near-colorless diamond look icier" while yellow gold "looks best with diamonds with faint color", and adds that "larger diamonds may reveal more warmth" (Blue Nile's diamond colour education page, checked 17 November 2026). On that advice a 5 carat stone is a reason to stay in the upper part of the near-colourless range, or above it, for a white-metal setting, with more room in yellow gold.
Clarity. GIA describes VS inclusions as "observed with effort" under 10× magnification and SI inclusions as "noticeable" under 10×, and grades clarity on the "number, size, relief, nature, and location" of those characteristics (GIA, checked 17 November 2026). Blue Nile's clarity guide says "as diamond size increases, clarity characteristics may become easier to detect", that "many larger diamonds can still appear beautifully eye clean", and that SI2 inclusions "may be detectable to a keen unaided eye" (Blue Nile's diamond clarity education page, checked 17 November 2026). VS2 is a cautious floor at this size; an SI1 stone needs its magnified photos or video looked at, because the grade alone does not say where the inclusions sit.
Setting. GIA's advice on protecting an engagement ring says "a six-prong setting can offer more protection than a four-prong setting": if a prong breaks, six are "more likely to hold the diamond in place", and the extra two may give the girdle, the stone's outer edge, a little more protection in daily wear. It adds that a bezel, a thin strip of metal around the stone, helps prevent the stone from falling out, and that it is a good idea to have the prongs checked every six months (GIA, 26 September 2017, checked 17 November 2026). That article is about engagement rings in general, not 5 carat stones; the stakes are simply higher when the stone costs this much.
Online vs in-store
Every price on this page comes from an online listing. Our tracker reads no shop-window prices, so this guide does not say which is cheaper. What the sample does show is how few stones there are to choose from: the two online sellers we sample listed 2 natural 5 carat G/VS1 rounds between them on 1 November 2026, and none on 14 October 2026. On those counts, a buyer set on a natural stone at this weight may have to look at more than one grade, or wait.
Buying online means paying before you see the stone, so the return terms carry the weight a shop visit would. From our review evidence: Blue Nile gives free insured returns within 30 days of the shipment date, capped at two free returns per customer a year (checked 31 October 2026). Brilliant Earth gives free 30-day returns with a prepaid label and no restocking fee, but its 30 days start when the order is ready to ship, not when it arrives, and resized, engraved and custom pieces are excluded (checked 31 October 2026). Read the current terms yourself before paying.
Whichever way you buy, the grading report is the check on what you were sold: look at the magnified images or video of the actual stone, read the report, and compare the two. GIA's ring-protection article, linked above, notes that insurers often ask for an appraisal to set a ring's replacement value, so plan for one when you insure it.
Where to buy a 5 carat diamond
These are the two retailers our tracker samples, plus one specialist. We earn a commission if you buy through the Brilliant Earth and Blue Nile buttons, and that does not change the prices above. Our Blue Nile review and Brilliant Earth review set out each one's returns, warranty and customer-review record; on our published method Brilliant Earth scores 4.3 out of 5 and Blue Nile 3.9 out of 5. At this price, look at the magnified images or video of the actual stone and read the grading report before you pay.
Brilliant Earth
Brilliant Earth names every loose stone by its cut grade (Ideal or Super Ideal), colour and clarity, which is what lets us sample it automatically: the Brilliant Earth prices above come straight from its listings. In our 1 November 2026 sample it was the only source of lab-grown 5 carat prices, with 27 stones of this grade. Filter its loose-stone search to the exact grade you want and compare what you see against the dated figure before you buy.
Blue Nile
Blue Nile is the other retailer in our sample; its lowest natural 5 carat G/VS1 round on 1 November 2026 was $174,304, among 2 stones of that grade. Its natural diamonds carry GIA reports and its lab-grown diamonds IGI reports, US shipping is free, and returns are free within 30 days of shipment, limited to two free returns per customer a year (policies checked 31 October 2026; see our review). It also offers a diamond price match on certified loose colourless diamonds; its terms say the competitor's diamond must be "comparable to our diamonds and have a verifiable, competing price", that Blue Nile decides "in our sole discretion" whether it is comparable, and that the match "only applies before you purchase" (terms on Blue Nile's diamond price match page, checked 17 November 2026).
Whiteflash
Whiteflash is not in our tracker and we have not scored it, and this link carries no affiliate tracking. It is here for buyers who want a natural stone selected on cut. Whiteflash says its A CUT ABOVE diamonds "must first receive GIA's highest grade for cut quality (Triple Excellent)", must also qualify for the AGS Ideal addendum report issued by GIA, and then pass its own tests, including light-performance imaging and a Hearts and Arrows pattern (Whiteflash, checked 17 November 2026). Those are the seller's criteria for its own brand, not an outside grade, and we have no price sample for it or any count of the 5 carat stones it lists.
Visit WhiteflashA CUT ABOVE: Whiteflash's own cut-selected natural diamondsVisit →Frequently asked questions
How big is a 5 carat diamond?
A 5 carat round brilliant is about 11 mm across: 10.97 mm on the size chart published by the diamond search site StoneAlgo, which gives 10.18 mm for a 4 carat round. StoneAlgo says it averaged the measurements of diamonds listed at online retailers and that each figure is "a typical value"; a single stone can measure more or less depending on how it is cut. Carat is a weight, not a width: GIA defines a metric carat as 200 milligrams, so a 5 carat diamond weighs one gram. Sources: StoneAlgo's round diamond size chart (updated 14 November 2026) and GIA on carat weight, both checked 17 November 2026. Our 3 carat guide uses a different chart, Lumera's, which stops at 3 carats; the two differ by about a tenth of a millimetre where they overlap.
Is a 5 carat lab diamond real?
Yes, it is a diamond. The grading laboratory GIA says laboratory-grown diamonds have "nearly the same chemical, optical and physical properties as natural diamonds", and that it tells the two apart with screening equipment and advanced laboratory testing. The paperwork is different, though. Since 1 October 2025 GIA has described a lab-grown diamond as "Premium" or "Standard" and no longer gives it a colour or clarity grade, while the laboratory IGI has said it will keep grading lab-grown diamonds on the 4Cs. Sources: GIA on laboratory-grown diamonds and GIA's notice of 26 August 2025, both checked 17 November 2026. IGI's statement is quoted, with its source, in our diamond certification guide.
Can I wear a 5 carat ring every day?
That is a matter of taste and of how you use your hands, and we have not worn or tested one. A stone about 11 mm across is much wider than a 1 carat stone, so ask the jeweller how far the setting stands off the finger and how the prongs protect the edge of the stone, and insure the ring. GIA's advice on protecting a ring says "a six-prong setting can offer more protection than a four-prong setting", because if a prong breaks six are more likely to hold the diamond in place, and that it is a good idea to have the prongs checked every six months. Source: GIA, 26 September 2017, checked 17 November 2026.
Do 5 carat diamonds hold their value?
Do not buy one expecting to get the money back. Trade sources quoted in our lab diamond resale guide say lab-grown stones resell for little or nothing, and a jewellers' trade body says only that a high-quality natural diamond "may" hold its value. The prices on this page are what retailers were asking on the sample date, not what a seller would be paid. See our lab diamond resale value guide for the sources.
How does a 5 carat moissanite compare with a diamond?
Moissanite is a different material, silicon carbide, not diamond. A GIA laboratory note says synthetic moissanite "is sometimes mistaken for diamond because some of its properties approach those of diamond", but that it has "a much higher dispersion (leading to more obvious fire)" and double refraction. It is also less dense: the same note gives specific gravities of 3.22 for moissanite and 3.52 for diamond, so a moissanite the same size as a 5 carat diamond weighs less than 5 carats. Our tracker samples diamonds only, so this guide gives no moissanite price. Source: GIA, Gems & Gemology, Fall 2020, checked 17 November 2026.
Always check the grading report before you buy. At 5 carats a natural diamond is above the weight limits of GIA's shorter reports: GIA lists its Diamond Dossier for stones of 0.15 to 1.99 carats and its digital eReport for 0.15 to 2.99 carats, so the GIA reports that apply at this weight are the ones with a plotted clarity diagram, the Diamond Grading Report and the Diamond Origin Report (GIA's diamond grading services page, checked 17 November 2026). Our diamond certification guide sets out which GIA reports are issued at which weights and what each laboratory puts on its report. Blue Nile sells its loose diamonds with GIA or IGI reports (checked 31 October 2026), and Brilliant Earth says its diamonds come with reports from GIA, IGI or GCAL (checked 31 October 2026; both per our review evidence), so at this price there is no reason to accept a stone without one.
Our investment-grade jewelry guide looks at resale across jewellery more widely. Read it with the resale sources above in mind: we do not suggest buying a 5 carat diamond, natural or lab-grown, as an investment.
Correction, 17 November 2026: An earlier version of this guide gave "typical" prices for five grades of 5 carat diamond, from D/Flawless ($8,500–$11,000 lab-grown, $280,000–$400,000+ natural) to J/SI1 ($3,000–$4,000 lab-grown, $60,000–$85,000 natural), and said a natural H/VS2 stone typically costs $100,000–$150,000 in one place and $100,000–$135,000 in another. None of those figures had a source. For the one grade our tracker samples, G/VS1, its natural range ($120,000–$160,000) was below the lowest natural price the tracker recorded on 1 November 2026 and its lab-grown range ($5,000–$6,500) was above both the lowest and the median lab-grown price. They have been removed; every price on the page is now read from our tracker, with the number of listings behind it. The guide said lab-grown 5 carat stones "sit at the upper bound of stable production"; that had no source, and one retailer listed 27 of a single grade in our 1 November 2026 sample. It called natural D Flawless stones "investment-grade" and "blue-chip jewellery" while saying elsewhere that resale is well below retail; the investment wording has been removed. It said a D/VVS lab-grown stone costs 3–4% of the natural equivalent and that the gap "continues to widen"; we sample no D/VVS stones and have no trend figures. It said lab-grown diamonds are "identical" to mined ones; GIA's wording is "nearly the same chemical, optical and physical properties". Statements with no source have been removed: that fancy shapes cost 15–25% less than rounds, that a J colour stone reads visibly yellow at 5 carats, that SI inclusions are visible to the naked eye, that a setting must be platinum or 18k gold and "never lower", that online retailers use "virtual inventory and centralised vaults" with lower overhead than shops, that a 5 carat round is roughly the width of an aspirin tablet, and that a 5 carat-equivalent moissanite typically costs $300–$600. The moissanite question in the FAQ was reworded because the guide has no moissanite prices. It called Whiteflash's A CUT ABOVE diamonds "the gold standard". The guide said our certification guide explains which reports are most reliable at this weight; that guide lists which GIA reports are issued at which weights, and this page now says so. Sections on how the price climbs with carat weight and on what the setting adds are new.
More diamond pricing guides
Diamond Price Per Carat — Complete Hub
The full pricing hub spanning every popular carat weight, with shape, colour and clarity breakdowns.
1.5 Carat Diamond Price Guide
Sweet-spot size between 1 and 2 carat — typical pricing, magic-weight tips and retailer comparison.
2 Carat Diamond Price Guide
The threshold where natural prices climb steeply. Lab vs natural and shape pricing breakdown.
2.5 Carat Diamond Price Guide
Statement-piece sizing. Where to compromise on grades and how to verify retailer pricing.
3 Carat Diamond Price Guide
Major-statement carat weight. Per-carat pricing scales geometrically — see live retailer data.
4 Carat Diamond Price Guide
Every flaw is magnified. Cut, clarity and colour rules for stones at this size.
Live Diamond Price Tracker
Monthly-sampled retailer pricing across major lab and natural diamond specs.
Published by David Adams, founder of TheCaratCut. Most guides were first drafted with AI tools and are being re-checked against their sources, with AI help; every correction is approved by David before it goes live. Our recommendations follow our editorial policy. We may earn commissions through affiliate links — see our disclosure.
