Last updated:

2026 Price Chart: Lab-Grown vs. Natural Diamond Trends

Lab-grown vs natural diamond prices from 1 to 5 carats, read from dated retailer listings, with analyst figures showing how the gap has grown since 2016.

David Adams
Founder, TheCaratCut

Founder of TheCaratCut. Director and software engineer with experience leading software for UFC, Al Jazeera, AMCN, The Economist, and The NHS. Director at Wayfinity, founder of Seat and Stone, and runs The Developer Safe Place mentorship community. Not a GIA-certified gemologist, and nothing here has been bought or tested — articles draw on retailers' published policies, prices and certificates and on customer-review sites. Most were first drafted with AI tools and are being re-checked against their sources, with AI help; every correction is approved by David before it goes live.

Published:
Last reviewed and updated 18 November 2026 by The Carat Cut editorial team. The November 2026 prices on this page are read from retailer listings by our Diamond Price Tracker. We have not bought or handled any of these stones, and we are not gemologists.

Key takeaways

  • •On 1 November 2026, the lowest listed 1 carat lab-grown round (G colour, VS1 clarity, top cut grades) in our sample was $510 at Brilliant Earth; the lowest natural stone of the same grade was $2,880 at Brilliant Earth. That is 82% cheaper.
  • •From 1 to 5 carats, the lowest lab-grown listing was 82% to 97% cheaper than the lowest natural one. The gap is generally wider for bigger stones.
  • •In a January 2023 note, analyst Paul Zimnisky put the gap at about 10% in 2016 and at as much as 80% by the end of 2022.
  • •Expect a lab-grown diamond to resell for very little. Natural diamonds are not a sure store of value either.

You want to know how much less a lab-grown diamond costs than a natural one, and how that gap has changed. This page gives two things: the prices we read from retailer listings on 1 November 2026, by carat weight, and what diamond analysts have published about earlier years. The two are measured differently, so we keep them in separate tables.

Lab-Grown vs. Natural Prices by Carat Weight

Each row compares round diamonds of the same weight and grade: G colour, VS1 clarity, in the top cut grades each retailer uses (Ideal or Super Ideal at Brilliant Earth, Excellent or Ideal at Blue Nile). Prices are advertised list prices in US dollars for loose stones, before any promo code and without a setting. “From” is the cheapest in-spec stone we found; the median is the middle price of all the in-spec stones a retailer listed that day.

Round, G colour, VS1 clarity: listings sampled 1 November 2026
CaratLab-grownNaturalLab-grown is cheaper byLab-grown price as a share of natural (lowest listings)
1.00 ct
From $510
Brilliant Earth; median $540 at Brilliant Earth
From $2,880
Brilliant Earth; median $4,180 at Blue Nile and $4,495 at Brilliant Earth
82% (lowest)
87% to 88% (medians)
18%
1.50 ct
From $920
Brilliant Earth; median $960 at Brilliant Earth
From $7,390
Brilliant Earth; median $11,860 at Blue Nile and $9,960 at Brilliant Earth
88% (lowest)
90% to 92% (medians)
12%
2.00 ct
From $1,320
Brilliant Earth; median $2,160 at Brilliant Earth
From $14,390
Brilliant Earth; median $24,226 at Blue Nile and $22,180 at Brilliant Earth
91% (lowest)
90% to 91% (medians)
9.2%
2.50 ct
From $2,180
Brilliant Earth; median $2,780 at Brilliant Earth
From $22,850
Brilliant Earth; median $35,268 at Blue Nile and $32,150 at Brilliant Earth
90% (lowest)
91% to 92% (medians)
9.5%
3.00 ct
From $2,570
Brilliant Earth; median $4,660 at Brilliant Earth
From $42,782
Blue Nile; median $55,533 at Blue Nile and $52,310 at Brilliant Earth
94% (lowest)
91% to 92% (medians)
6.0%
4.00 ct
From $3,650
Brilliant Earth; median $7,180 at Brilliant Earth
From $81,654
Blue Nile; median $96,646 at Blue Nile
96% (lowest)
93% (medians)
4.5%
5.00 ct
From $4,790
Brilliant Earth; median $4,850 at Brilliant Earth
From $174,304
Blue Nile; median $177,496 at Blue Nile
97% (lowest)
97% (medians)
2.7%

Source: our Diamond Price Tracker, sample of 1 November 2026. Lab-grown prices come from Brilliant Earth’s loose-stone product feed, the only lab-grown source the tracker reads automatically; natural prices come from Brilliant Earth’s feed and Blue Nile’s public listings. Blue Nile shows its first 32 best matches without a price sort, so where it lists more than that its lowest price is the lowest of those 32, not necessarily of all its stock. A retailer that listed no in-spec stone is left out of that row. Two retailers are not the whole market, so read these as reference prices, not a market floor.

Read the 1 carat row this way. The cheapest lab-grown stone was $510 and the cheapest natural stone was $2,880, a gap of 82%. Medians tell you about a typical listing, not the cheapest one: the lab-grown median was $540 at Brilliant Earth, against natural medians of $4,180 at Blue Nile and $4,495 at Brilliant Earth, which makes a typical lab-grown stone 87% to 88% cheaper. The bar in the last column shows the same thing the other way round: the lab-grown price as a share of the natural price. It is smallest at the largest sizes, because natural prices climb much faster with size than lab-grown prices do.

How to Read the Chart

Lowest and median answer different questions. For lab-grown stones the two can sit close together or far apart: at 5.00 ct the median ($4,850) was 1% above the lowest listing ($4,790), while at 4.00 ct the median ($7,180) was 97% above the lowest ($3,650). Stones that share a weight, a colour grade and a clarity grade are still not identical, so where the gap is wide, look at how the cheapest stones differ from the rest before choosing one.

Each median rests on a count of stones. A lab-grown stone counts for a row if it weighs between the stated weight and 0.05 carat above it. The sample of 1 November 2026 counted 518 in-spec lab-grown stones across the 7 weights, from 27 at 5.00 ct to 146 at 2.00 ct. Brilliant Earth, the source of the lab-grown prices, is an affiliate partner of this site, and the listing links on the tracker page are affiliate links.

Set any quote beside the median. If a jeweler quotes you a price for a stone of this grade, compare it with the median for that weight and ask what accounts for the difference: a setting, a brand, a service plan, or nothing.

Price per carat changes with size. The lowest 1.00 ct lab-grown stone worked out at $510 per carat and the lowest 3.00 ct stone at $857 per carat. Weight thresholds matter too. GIA’s page on carat weight (checked 17 November 2026) says: “Certain carat weights are considered to be magic sizes for their desirability – 1.00 carat, 1.50 carats, and 2.00 carats. Although it is difficult to visually distinguish a 0.99 carat diamond from a 1.00 carat, the price difference can be significant.” GIA is writing about diamonds in general, and our tracker only samples stones at or just above each threshold, so we have no price for a stone just under one.

Other shapes. Every row above is a round. The tracker samples one lab-grown fancy shape: a 2.00 ct oval, F colour, VS1 clarity. On 1 November 2026 its lowest listing was $2,060 and its median $3,090, against $1,320 and $2,160 for the 2.00 ct round. The oval is one colour grade higher (F, not G), so the two are not a like-for-like comparison. Price a fancy shape from listings of that shape, not from the round table.

The Five-Year Cost Evolution

Our tracker has read prices automatically only since October 2026, so it cannot show a five-year trend. For earlier years we rely on figures that diamond analysts have published. They are the analysts’ own averages and are not measured the way our tracker measures. Do not chain them to the table above.

Published analyst figures, 2016 to 2025
WhenFigureWho said it, and where
2016A 1 carat lab-grown diamond sold for about 10% less than an equivalent natural onePaul Zimnisky, “Lab-Diamond Sales Grow as Prices Fall”, January 2023
2016Generic lab-grown diamond: $5,450 per carat. Generic natural diamond: $6,538 per carat. By our arithmetic that is 17% less.Clarisa Diaz in Quartz, updated August 2023, citing data by Paul Zimnisky
2018The discount on a generic 1 carat lab-created diamond against a comparable natural one rose from 29% in January to 42% in late November. When De Beers’ Lightbox launched in late September, an equivalent-quality 1 carat generic lab-created diamond “was selling for around $3,700.”Paul Zimnisky, “2018: The year of the lab-created diamond”, mining.com, 2018
January 2020A 1 carat round lab-grown diamond retailed for 35% less than a comparable natural oneEdahn Golan, quoted by National Jeweler, September 2023
Early 20211 carat lab-grown: $1,980Zimnisky’s State of the Diamond Market report, as reported by National Jeweler, February 2023
End of 2022The gap between 1 carat lab-grown and natural had widened to “as much as 80%”Zimnisky, January 2023 (same note as the 2016 row)
Early 20231 carat lab-grown: $1,450, down 27% in two yearsZimnisky, as reported by National Jeweler, February 2023 (same article as the 2021 row)
August 2023Generic lab-grown diamond: $1,425 per carat. Generic natural diamond: $5,185 per carat. By our arithmetic that is 73% less. Quartz puts the fall since 2016 at about 74% for lab-grown and almost 21% for natural.Quartz, August 2023, citing data by Zimnisky (same article as the second 2016 row)
Autumn 20231 to 3 carat lab-grown diamonds at retail priced at an average 80% discount (Zimnisky); retail gap of 76% (Golan)Both quoted by National Jeweler, September 2023 (same article as the 2020 row)
Early 2025Unbranded round 1 carat lab-grown: $845 on average. A similar natural diamond: about $3,895. By our arithmetic that is 78% less.Zimnisky, quoted by CNBC, March 2025

Sources checked 16 November 2026.

The table holds two different statements of the 2016 gap. Zimnisky’s own January 2023 note says a 1 carat lab-grown diamond sold for “only 10% less” than an equivalent natural one; the per-carat prices Quartz attributes to his data work out at 17% less. We give each as its source states it and do not reconcile them.

One 2018 figure can be set beside our tracker, because it names the same retailer and grade. A footnote to Zimnisky’s mining.com article reads: “A loose 2-carat, G-color, VS1-clarity lab-created diamond is currently offered for $10,100 on Brilliant Earth.” On 1 November 2026, the lowest 2.00 ct lab-grown G/VS1 round in Brilliant Earth’s feed was $1,320, and the median was $2,160. By our arithmetic the lowest listing is 87% below the 2018 price and the median is 79% below it. The footnote does not state the 2018 stone’s shape or cut grade, so this is a rough comparison, not a like-for-like one.

Read together, Zimnisky’s three 1 carat figures ($1,980, $1,450, $845) show the average lab-grown price falling by more than half between early 2021 and early 2025 (our arithmetic on his figures). Over a longer span, he told The New York Times that lab-grown diamond prices fell by about 85% between January 2015 and January 2025, as Money reported in April 2026.

Natural prices have fallen too. Money’s report says diamond prices “have plunged by 50% since 2022,” puts much of that down to “the surging production of lab-created diamonds,” and says the supply glut dragged down the prices of mined diamonds as well. So the gap has widened while both prices fell.

What the Price History Means for a Buyer

Check the date on every price. An article, a forum post or a quote from last year describes a different market. Our own samples show movement inside a single month: over the 18 days between 14 October 2026 and 1 November 2026, the lowest lab-grown listing was lower at 5 of the 7 sizes we track. Two samples are too few to call a trend.

One analyst expects more falls. Edahn Golan told Money in April 2026 (checked 17 November 2026) that prices will “continue to decline for lab-grown.” That is a forecast, not a fact. If it proves right, the stone you buy today will cost less to buy new later.

What falling prices mean for selling a stone and for insuring one is covered under Comparing Resale Value and in the insurance question further down this page.

Why Lab-Grown Prices Dropped

There are two ways to grow a diamond. The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) describes HPHT (High Pressure High Temperature) as “mimicking some of the key conditions of diamond formation”: a capsule holding a carbon source and a mixture of metals is heated under high pressure. CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition) is different. GIA says it “occurs at near-vacuum pressure,” with a plasma releasing carbon that settles onto diamond seeds. Both descriptions are from GIA’s page on laboratory-grown diamonds (checked 16 November 2026).

Growing takes weeks. Writing in 2018, Zimnisky said “the process of growing a 2.5-carat rough lab-created diamond (the approximate size that yields a 1-carat polished) typically takes 3-4 weeks, plus additional time to cut the diamond and manufacture the jewelry.” That is a 2018 statement, from his mining.com article.

The price fall is a supply story. CNBC’s 2025 report says “prices for lab-grown diamonds have been dropping as manufacturers increase the supply.” Growers say the same: Smit Patel of Greenlab Diamonds told National Jeweler in 2023 that there was “overcapacity in production” and that the “surge in supply has outpaced consumer demand.” Analyst Edahn Golan put it to Money in four words: “Supply completely outdid demand.” Sales grew as well: Quartz, citing Zimnisky’s data, reported that “lab-grown diamond jewelry sales grew globally to almost $12 billion in 2022, up 38% year-over-year,” and that “India and China account for around 75% of global lab-grown diamond jewelry production by volume.”

Are CVD or HPHT Lab-Grown Diamonds Better?

Neither growth method wins by default. GIA’s longer account of the two processes puts numbers on them: an HPHT growth chamber is heated “to 1300-1600 °C with pressures above 870,000 pounds per square inch”, while a CVD diamond “grows in thin layers” from a hydrocarbon gas mixture “in a vacuum chamber” (GIA, 25 July 2016, checked 17 November 2026).

CVD diamonds can show a brown tint or strain. The same GIA article says CVD crystals “display a brown color that can be removed by heat treatment prior to faceting” and “tend to display banded ‘strain’ patterns”, and an article in GIA’s journal says that since 2020 “approximately 80% of the CVD diamonds submitted to GIA have undergone post-growth processing” (Gems & Gemology, Summer 2024, checked 17 November 2026). HPHT diamonds can show a blue nuance from boron: “The addition of boron in the growth process results in blue crystals”, GIA’s 2016 article says, and in colourless HPHT-grown diamonds, the 2024 article says, “boron is usually incorporated accidentally”.

So the choice depends on the individual stone, not the label. Avoid a stone with visible brown or blue body colour unless the price reflects it and you like the tone. The comments on the grading report can state the growth method and whether the stone was treated after growth; the report walk-through further down this page shows where.

The two methods also map onto where stones are grown. The same Gems & Gemology article cites a Bain & Company estimate that 6 to 7 million carats of gem-quality lab-grown diamonds were produced worldwide in 2020: about 3 million in China, mostly by HPHT, about 1.5 million in India, mostly by CVD, and about 1 million in the United States. Many of India’s growers are based in Surat, in Gujarat, which the article describes as the world’s leading diamond cutting and polishing center.

Comparing Resale Value

Neither kind of diamond is a reliable way to get your money back, but they are not equal. CNBC reported in March 2025, citing Amanda Gizzi of Jewelers of America, that lab-grown diamonds “do not hold their value and will likely sell for less than what you initially paid for.” The article then adds, in its own words, that “a high-quality natural diamond or gemstone may hold its value, or even appreciate.” Note the “may”. The same CNBC report says engagement rings “are not considered investments.”

For lab-grown stones, Zimnisky told CNBC in 2023: “It’s very difficult to resell a lab diamond.” Difficult is not the same as impossible. Our lab diamond resale guide documents the routes that exist: a retailer upgrade credit, with the conditions attached to it, and private listings where you set the price yourself. It also names buyers that refuse lab-grown stones outright. Falling prices for new stones are the reason offers are low: a buyer has little reason to pay you much for a stone that costs less to buy new each year.

The smaller purchase price cuts the other way. At the 1 carat prices above, the most a lab-grown buyer can lose on the stone is $510; a natural buyer who paid $2,880 would need to resell for more than $2,370 to lose less than that. Get a real offer on a natural stone before you count on it.

How to Choose Between Them

Base the decision on your budget and on what you want the stone to be, not on what it might be worth later.

  • Choose Lab-Grown if: Your budget is fixed and you want a larger stone for it. The table above shows how much further the same money goes. You accept that you are unlikely to get much back if you sell.
  • Choose Natural if: A mined stone’s rarity or tradition matters to you and you are willing to pay several times more for it. Do not buy one on the assumption that it will hold its price.

The two buttons below go to the two retailers our tracker reads, so you can check today’s listings against the dated figures above. They are affiliate links: we may earn a commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you.

Which Lab-Grown Diamond Specs to Buy

Buy a lab-grown diamond with a grading report, an excellent or ideal cut, and eye-clean clarity. For most engagement rings, the best balance sits at G to I colour and VS2 to SI1 clarity. A GIA document issued for a lab-grown diamond since 1 October 2025 gives “Premium” or “Standard” in place of colour and clarity grades, and GIA’s minimum clarity for Standard is Very Slightly included (see GIA’s Premium and Standard Assessments further down this page). So on a newly assessed stone those letter grades will come from a laboratory that still issues them. IGI has said it “will continue applying the universal 4Cs grading to all diamonds, whether natural or lab-grown” (Rapaport, 15 July 2025, checked 17 November 2026).

Give cut more weight than colour or clarity. GIA describes a diamond’s cut as “how it interacts with light” and says “Proportions impact the face-up appearance, allure and attractiveness of diamonds” (GIA, checked 17 November 2026). Do not overpay for D colour or flawless clarity unless you have already secured top cut quality. GIA’s own advice on saving money asks “Do you need to splurge on a diamond in the GIA Colorless range (D, E, or F color)? Probably not.” and says “Most SI diamonds will also not have any eye-visible inclusions” (GIA, 3 October 2023, checked 17 November 2026).

Round brilliant diamonds offer the most standardized cut data. For round stones, target a table near 54% to 58%, a crown angle near 34 to 35 degrees, and a pavilion angle near 40.6 to 41 degrees. Those targets are narrower than GIA’s own bands: GIA says an Excellent grade diamond “will have a table size between 52 and 62 percent”, that the crown angle in a well-cut diamond “will be within 31.5 to 36.5 degrees”, and that the pavilion angle should fall “between 40.6 and 41.8 degrees”, “providing other parameters also fit their proper ranges” (GIA, 9 April 2014, checked 17 November 2026). These ranges do not guarantee beauty, but they remove many weak performers before you inspect video.

Fancy shapes need visual review because reports give less predictive cut data: GIA says its “cut grades are only given to round brilliant cut diamonds” (same GIA page on cut). Oval, radiant, pear, and marquise cuts can show bow-tie contrast, crushed-ice texture, and uneven brightness even with high colour and clarity grades. Emerald and asscher cuts expose inclusions and colour more easily, so many buyers should move from SI1 to VS2 or VS1 in those shapes. GIA’s shape guide says the emerald cut “tends to show inclusions and color more easily than other shapes” and that “it is best to select emeralds cuts with a grade of VS2 clarity and G color or above” (GIA, 21 November 2025, checked 17 November 2026).

Specs by buyer goal, with the nearest lab-grown price in our tracker on 1 November 2026
Buyer goalBest practical specWhy it worksNearest price in our tracker
Best overall value1.50 ct, H colour, VS2, excellent cutStrong size with little visible compromise1.5 ct round, G/VS1: from $920, median $960
Best 2 carat value2.00 ct, G to I colour, VS2 to SI1Large face-up size without paying for D or IF grades2 ct round, G/VS1: from $1,320, median $2,160
Best premium look2.00 ct, F colour, VS1, ideal cutHigher colour and clarity with strong optics2 ct oval, F/VS1: from $2,060, median $3,090
Best emerald cut1.70 ct, F to G colour, VS1Step cuts show colour and inclusions fasterOur tracker does not sample emerald cuts
Best budget pick1.00 ct, H to I colour, SI1 eye-cleanKeeps cost low while retaining real diamond material1 ct round, G/VS1: from $510, median $540

The prices are lab-grown list prices at Brilliant Earth on 1 November 2026, from our Diamond Price Tracker: the cheapest stone of that grade and the median across the stones listed. The tracker samples G colour and VS1 clarity in rounds and one 2 carat oval, so each row shows the nearest stone it records, not the exact spec in the second column.

Which Diamond Shapes Give the Best Value

Round brilliant cuts usually cost more per carat. GIA gives two reasons: “their immense popularity and the fact that more of the crystal is lost during the cutting process” make round brilliants “often the most expensive diamond shape” (GIA, 10 June 2025, checked 17 November 2026). They also offer the easiest performance screening because cut grades and proportions give useful data. If you want a cut grade on the report, round is the shape that gets one.

Oval cuts often give more face-up spread per carat. A 2.00 carat oval can look larger than a 2.00 carat round: GIA’s oval guide says the shape “offers a larger surface area than round diamonds of the same carat weight”. Inspect the bow-tie area in the center, because a dark band can reduce brightness in normal lighting. The same guide says “some degree of bow tie is always present” and that “a well-cut oval diamond will minimize the bow tie” (GIA, 23 September 2025, checked 17 November 2026).

Emerald cuts deliver a clean, linear look, but they punish weak clarity. A VS2 inclusion that hides in a round brilliant may sit in the open table of an emerald cut. For step cuts, many buyers should choose VS1 or better and stay near F to G colour if the setting uses platinum or white gold. That is a step stricter than GIA’s shape guide, quoted above, which puts the floor at VS2 clarity and G colour.

ShapeValue strengthMain riskPractical target
RoundStrongest light return dataHigher price per caratExcellent or ideal cut, H VS2
OvalLarge face-up sizeBow-tie contrastG to H VS2, inspect video
RadiantBright flashes in a rectangular shapeCrushed-ice textureG to I VS2 or SI1 eye-clean
EmeraldClean geometryInclusions show fastF to G VS1
CushionSoft outline and lower costDepth can hide weightG to I VS2

Our tracker samples one lab-grown fancy shape, a 2.00 ct oval; its price is under How to Read the Chart, above.

What to Check on a Listing

Go through these before you compare prices, because two listings are only comparable when they match on all of them.

  1. The exact weight. Listings round. Our table counts lab-grown stones from the stated weight to 0.05 carat above it, so a 1.04 ct stone and a 1.00 ct stone are in the same row; a 0.95 ct stone is not.
  2. Loose stone or finished ring. Every price in the table is for a loose stone. A ring price includes a setting, so it cannot be set against the table directly.
  3. The cut grade, for a round. The table only counts the top cut grades each retailer uses. A lower cut grade is a different stone at a different price.
  4. The grading laboratory and report number. The listing should name the laboratory and give the report number. Ritani’s lab-grown stones carry IGI or GCAL reports with the report number in the listing (Ritani, checked 31 October 2026). Clean Origin says every lab-grown center stone is independently graded, mainly by IGI and GCAL, and laser-inscribed with its report number (Clean Origin, checked 31 October 2026).
  5. The price you would pay, not the price before a discount. Sale banners are not comparable across shops. Clean Origin ran “40% off select styles” in July 2026 and “25% off Sitewide - Prices as Marked” in September 2026 (Clean Origin, checked 31 October 2026). Compare what each shop charges at checkout.
  6. The return window, and when it starts. Brilliant Earth gives 30 days, counted from when the order is ready to ship, not from delivery; resized, engraved and custom pieces are excluded (its returns page, checked 31 October 2026; details in our Brilliant Earth review). Ritani gives 30 days, limited to two returns or exchanges a year (Ritani, checked 31 October 2026). Clean Origin gives 60 days with free shipping both ways, but refunds custom orders as store credit only (Clean Origin, checked 31 October 2026).
  7. The date. A price is only good on the day it was read, ours included. The table states its sample date for that reason.

What to Check on the Grading Report

A grading report is the document the price rests on, so read it before you pay. Here is what one says, using a real example: IGI report LG564355744, dated January 12, 2023, for a 0.70 carat round, as published by the retailer Ritani (checked 17 November 2026). A report issued today may be laid out differently.

  • Title and description. The report is headed “LABORATORY GROWN DIAMOND REPORT” and its description line reads “LABORATORY GROWN DIAMOND”. This is the line that tells you what the stone is.
  • Report number. “IGI Report Number LG564355744”. It should match the number on the listing.
  • Shape and measurements. “ROUND BRILLIANT”, “5.64 - 5.68 X 3.53 MM”. Measurements tell you how wide the stone is; weight alone does not.
  • Grading results. Carat weight, colour grade, clarity grade and cut grade (here “0.70 CARAT”, “D”, “VVS 2” and “IDEAL”), then polish, symmetry and fluorescence.
  • Inscription. “LABGROWN”, the laboratory’s mark and the report number. The report shows it under the label “LASERSCRIBE”. The inscription ties the physical stone to the document.
  • Comments. On this report: “As Grown - No indication of post-growth treatment.” and “This Laboratory Grown Diamond was created by High Pressure High Temperature (HPHT) growth process.” Here the words “As Grown” sit beside the laboratory’s finding that it saw no sign of treatment after growth.
  • Verification. The report’s footer reads: “For terms & conditions and to verify this report, please visit www.igi.org”. Enter the report number on the laboratory’s own site and check that the details returned match the document you were sent.

The treatment line matters because lab-grown stones can be treated. GIA’s page on laboratory-grown diamonds (checked 17 November 2026) says: “An HPHT press can also be used to treat diamond color” and “Diamond treatments can also be used to enhance laboratory-grown diamonds.”

GIA’s Premium and Standard Assessments for Lab-Grown Diamonds

A GIA document for a lab-grown stone now looks different. In an announcement dated 26 August 2025 (checked 17 November 2026), GIA said it would launch revised services for D-to-Z lab-grown diamonds on 1 October 2025, with the previous services available until 30 September. Under the new service, lab-grown diamonds “will be described as ‘Premium’ or ‘Standard’ based on an overall assessment of their clarity, color and cut.” The announcement adds: “Any diamond that does not meet all the minimum criteria for ‘Standard’ will not receive a GIA assessment.” Premium requires D colour, clarity of “Very, Very Slightly included and higher”, Excellent polish and symmetry, and an Excellent cut grade for rounds. The minimum for Standard is colour “E-to-J”, clarity “Very Slightly included”, Very Good polish and symmetry (Good symmetry for fancy shapes) and a Very Good cut grade for rounds. Each stone’s girdle is laser-inscribed with the term “Laboratory-Grown” and the assessment number. The trade magazine JCK reported the change on 27 August 2025 (checked 17 November 2026).

Two things follow for a shopper. G colour and VS1 clarity, the grade in our table, meet GIA’s colour and clarity minimums for Standard but not its D colour requirement for Premium, so a document issued under the new service will not tell you those letter grades. And older GIA reports that do give colour and clarity for a lab-grown stone still count: GIA’s release of 2 June 2025 (checked 17 November 2026) says “Existing GIA reports for laboratory-grown diamonds remain valid.” You can look up a GIA document by its number with GIA Report Check.

What a Lab-Grown Engagement Ring Costs by Carat

Every price above is for a loose stone. A ring is a stone plus a setting, and retailers that sell loose stones price the two separately. Our tracker does not record setting prices. As one dated reading: on 16 November 2026 the first six settings shown on Blue Nile’s engagement ring page had list prices from $1,000 (a 14k gold petite solitaire) to $2,320 (an 18k gold solitaire), before a 20% sale discount that was running that day. Blue Nile listed 1,431 settings, so those six are a reading of the first page, not its cheapest or dearest.

Round, G colour, VS1 clarity: stones sampled 1 November 2026; settings read 16 November 2026
CaratCheapest lab-grown stoneThat stone plus a $1,000 to $2,320 setting
1.00 ct$510$1,510 to $2,830
1.50 ct$920$1,920 to $3,240
2.00 ct$1,320$2,320 to $3,640
2.50 ct$2,180$3,180 to $4,500
3.00 ct$2,570$3,570 to $4,890
4.00 ct$3,650$4,650 to $5,970
5.00 ct$4,790$5,790 to $7,110

The last column adds that setting range to the cheapest lab-grown stone at each weight. The stone prices are Brilliant Earth’s and the setting prices are Blue Nile’s, so the sum mixes two retailers. It shows the scale of a ring’s cost. It is not a quote. At 1.00 ct and 1.50 ct, the cheapest setting in that reading ($1,000) cost more than the cheapest lab-grown stone, so compare settings as carefully as stones.

Choosing the Setting and Metal

With a lab-grown stone the setting can be the larger part of the bill, so it deserves as much attention as the diamond.

How the stone is held. GIA’s guide to engagement ring settings (14 August 2026, checked 18 November 2026) says “Most round brilliant diamond rings use four or six prongs, depending on the size of the stone”, and “The larger the stone, the more prongs it needs.” That matters if a lab-grown budget buys you a larger stone. The trade-off, in GIA’s words: “Fewer prongs expose more of the gemstone, while additional prongs provide extra security.” It adds that “prongs should be checked occasionally to ensure they remain secure”. A bezel, a rim of metal around the stone, is the protective option: “Bezel settings offer excellent protection for the edges of the stone while creating a clean, modern look.”

The style around it. A solitaire, in the same guide, “features a single center gemstone with little or no additional decoration”. A halo surrounds the center stone with “a ring of smaller accent stones”, which “can make it appear larger”. Pavé, small stones set closely along the band, comes with two cautions from GIA: such rings “may require occasional maintenance to ensure the stones remain secure”, and “Pavé-set bands can also be more difficult to resize, since adjusting the ring may disturb the small stones.”

The metal. Karat is gold content. The World Gold Council’s table gives 14k gold as 58.3% gold, and says “18 carat gold contains 75 per cent gold and 25 per cent other metals” (World Gold Council, checked 18 November 2026). White gold is often rhodium plated, and GIA says “Rhodium plating will wear away gradually over time, requiring the ring to be replated occasionally” (GIA, 29 June 2015, checked 18 November 2026). Of platinum, the same article says it “makes for sturdy prongs”. On cost, a later GIA article says “Platinum currently costs less than gold, but the labor for creating platinum jewelry costs more”, so its price “is roughly comparable to that of white gold jewelry depending on the design and white gold karat” (GIA, 30 May 2025, checked 18 November 2026).

Before you choose a setting, check that it takes your stone’s shape and carat weight, and ask what resizing it allows.

Returns, Resizing and Warranty Compared

An engagement ring is often bought weeks before it is given, so check when the return window starts as well as how long it is. A window counted from shipment, or from when the order is ready to ship, can be partly used up before the ring is opened. We have not bought from any of these stores. This is what our reviews record for the four lab-grown diamond retailers we have scored under our published scoring rubric:

RetailerReturns, resizing and warranty, as recorded in our reviewOur score for returns and warrantyChecked
Brilliant EarthFree 30-day returns with a prepaid FedEx label and no restocking fee, but the clock starts when the order is ready to ship rather than on delivery, and resized, engraved and custom pieces are excluded. A free lifetime manufacturing warranty and one free resize (60 days, or 1 year within the sizing range) are included.8 out of 1031 October 2026
Rare CaratFree returns with a prepaid label and no restocking fee within 30 days of shipment (not delivery), plus one free resize in the first year. A lifetime manufacturing-defect warranty excludes wear, lost stones and theft.8 out of 1031 October 2026
Blue NileFree insured returns within 30 days of the shipment date, capped at two free returns per customer per year; its returns page, read on 18 November 2026, excludes custom orders, personalized and engraved jewelry, resized items and clearance or final-sale items, and states no restocking fee. The Limited Lifetime Warranty (effective Oct 11, 2026) covers only manufacturing defects on gold and platinum items of $1,000 or more, excludes lost or chipped stones, and the buyer pays shipping; one free resize within 6 months.7 out of 1031 October 2026
Clean Origin60-day returns with free shipping both ways, and a lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects that includes a prepaid insured label for warranty repairs; work by another jeweler voids it. Custom orders are refunded as store credit only, and a paid Forever Service Plan adds 35 years of extra cover.8 out of 1031 October 2026

Policies change. Read the retailer’s current returns page before you order, and get the resize and warranty terms in writing if the ring is custom, engraved or already resized.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a jeweler tell a lab diamond from a natural diamond?

Not by looking. GIA says a laboratory-grown diamond has “nearly the same chemical, optical and physical properties” as a natural one and that “by eye, the difference can potentially be indistinguishable.” Telling them apart takes what GIA calls “specially developed screening equipment and advanced testing at gemological laboratories.” GIA makes a desktop screening instrument for jewelers, so some can screen a stone in the shop; for a buyer, the grading report is the simpler check.

Will lab diamond prices go down even further?

Our own data is too short to say: between our two automated samples (14 October 2026 and 1 November 2026), the lowest 1 carat lab-grown listing stayed at $510 and the median stayed at $540. Two samples a few weeks apart cannot show a trend. The tracker also holds a May 2026 sample collected by hand across a different set of retailers; because the method changed, we do not compare it with these figures. We re-sample monthly and keep every snapshot on the Diamond Price Tracker.

Are lab diamonds considered real diamonds?

Yes. In 2018 the Federal Trade Commission removed the word “natural” from its definition of a diamond, reasoning that lab-grown stones have essentially the same properties as mined ones, as National Jeweler’s summary of the Jewelry Guides explains (checked 16 November 2026). Sellers must still say what they are selling: terms such as “laboratory-grown” or “laboratory-created” are allowed, and a lab-grown stone may not be called “natural” or “genuine.” The rule itself, 16 CFR 23.12 (eCFR text up to date as of 12 November 2026, checked 16 November 2026), reads: “A diamond is a mineral consisting essentially of pure carbon crystallized in the isometric system. It is found in many colors. Its hardness is 10; its specific gravity is approximately 3.52; and it has a refractive index of 2.42.” Among descriptions “that are not considered unfair or deceptive,” it lists use of the word “cultured” for “laboratory-created diamonds that have essentially the same optical, physical, and chemical properties as mined diamonds” when the term is qualified by a clear and conspicuous disclosure “conveying that the product is not a mined stone.” On the material itself, GIA describes diamond as typically about 99.95 percent carbon and so hard that only another diamond can scratch it.

Should I insure a lab-grown diamond?

You can. Jewelers Mutual, an insurer that sells jewelry cover and so has an interest in the answer, puts it this way in an article dated April 13, 2021 (checked 16 November 2026): “Can you insure a lab-grown diamond? Yes.” It adds: “Because mined diamonds and lab-grown diamonds are different, it is a good idea to have an appraisal done to accurately assess your diamond. This will help with insuring the diamond for its value if you need to file a claim for loss, disappearance, theft or damage.” For scale, a replacement 1 carat lab-grown G/VS1 round started at $510 in our 1 November 2026 sample, before the setting. An appraisal figure can go stale as prices move: the lowest 3.00 ct lab-grown listing in our sample went from $2,820 on 14 October 2026 to $2,570 on 1 November 2026, a change of 9%.

What is the best grade for a lab-grown diamond?

The best practical grade for most buyers is G to H colour, VS2 clarity, and an excellent or ideal cut. This range gives a clean face-up look without paying more for D colour or flawless clarity. Fancy shapes may need VS1 if inclusions sit under the table. The sources behind this are under Which Lab-Grown Diamond Specs to Buy, above.

How much should I spend on a lab-grown diamond?

On 1 November 2026 the cheapest 1.00 carat lab-grown round of G colour and VS1 clarity in our price tracker cost $510 at Brilliant Earth, where the median for that grade was $540. The cheapest 2.00 carat stone of the same grade cost $1,320, with a median of $2,160. Spend more only when cut quality, the grading report, video, and return policy support the price.

Is IGI or GIA better for lab-grown diamonds?

They no longer do the same job. IGI grades lab-grown diamonds on the 4Cs and said in July 2025 that it will continue to. Since 1 October 2025 GIA describes a lab-grown diamond only as Premium or Standard, with no colour or clarity grade, although GIA says its existing lab-grown reports remain valid. If you want a colour grade and a clarity grade on a newly assessed stone, the report has to come from a laboratory that still gives them, such as IGI. Avoid ungraded diamonds.

Do lab-grown diamonds hold their value?

Usually not. CNBC reported in March 2025, citing Amanda Gizzi of Jewelers of America, that lab-grown diamonds “do not hold their value and will likely sell for less than what you initially paid for.” Comparing Resale Value, above, has the detail. Buy a lab-grown diamond to wear, not to resell.

Final Step

Set your budget before you shop, then decide whether size or a mined origin matters more to you. Check the date on any price you compare, including ours.

For further analysis on grading metrics, read our guide on the 4 C's of Diamond Quality.

Correction, 16 November 2026: An earlier version of this guide said the price gap between natural and lab-grown diamonds “reached 95% in 2026” while its own table said 88%. It gave a year-by-year table of 1 carat prices for 2021 to 2025 (for example $3,500 for a lab-grown stone in 2021 and $450 in 2025) with no source; those rows have been removed and replaced with published analyst figures, which put a 1 carat lab-grown diamond at $1,980 in early 2021 and $845 in early 2025. It said lab-grown diamonds have zero secondary market value, that pawn shops reject them and that they cannot be traded in for an upgrade; upgrade credit and private listings exist, as our resale guide documents. It said natural diamonds can usually be sold back for 40% to 60% of their retail price and that most jewelers offer trade-in programs for them; both statements have been removed. It said both growing methods mirror the conditions that form diamonds in the earth (only HPHT does), that factories use renewable energy grids to yield perfect stones in weeks, that the stone cost is approaching zero, that lab-grown stones have a guaranteed conflict-free origin, and that insuring one carries a very low premium; all of these have been removed. The insurance answer now quotes an insurer’s own page. Prices on this page are now read directly from our Diamond Price Tracker. Correction, 17 November 2026: an earlier version quoted two sentences from a 2025 CNBC report as the direct words of Amanda Gizzi of Jewelers of America. The first is CNBC reporting what she said and the second is CNBC's own sentence; the text now says so. Update, 17 November 2026: our Lab Diamond Price Shopper’s Guide was merged into this page, which now carries its sections on reading the chart, checking a listing and a grading report, GIA’s Premium and Standard assessments and what the price history means for a buyer; its old address redirects here. Our Best Lab Grown Diamonds guide was also merged into this page on 17 November 2026, which now carries its sections on which specs and shapes to buy and on CVD and HPHT growth; its old address redirects here. Our Lab Grown Engagement Rings guide was merged into this page on 18 November 2026, which now carries its table of what a ring costs by carat, its section on choosing the setting and metal and its comparison of returns, resizing and warranty; its old address redirects here.

Published by David Adams, founder of TheCaratCut. Most guides were first drafted with AI tools and are being re-checked against their sources, with AI help; every correction is approved by David before it goes live. Our recommendations follow our editorial policy. We may earn commissions through affiliate links — see our disclosure.

✓Run by one named person, not a faceless team
✓Independent — no brand sponsorship
✓Affiliate links disclosed transparently
✓Editorial policy publicly available